Home services
Google Ads or Local Services Ads — which should a contractor run?
Run Local Services Ads first if your trade is eligible, because you pay per lead rather than per click and the ads sit above everything else on the page. Add Google Ads search underneath it for the jobs LSA does not categorise well and for the control it gives you over exact search terms. They are complementary rather than competing — LSA buys presence at the top, search buys precision.
The short version
- LSA charges per lead; Google Ads charges per click. That single difference drives most of the decision.
- LSA sits above the map pack and above search ads. Position is the product.
- LSA gives you little keyword control. Search ads give you all of it.
- Both need someone disputing bad leads and adding negatives, or costs drift upward quietly.
How to do it
Check eligibility and get verified early
Local Services Ads require background checks, licence and insurance verification. The process takes time, so start it before you need the leads rather than after.
Turn LSA on with a budget you can answer
The leads arrive as phone calls and they arrive fast. If nobody answers, you pay for the lead anyway and the responsiveness signal works against you.
Dispute bad leads every week
Wrong service, outside your area, spam. Google credits legitimate disputes, but only if you file them. Left alone this is a steady leak that never appears as a problem.
Add search ads on the terms LSA misses
Specific jobs, brand names, commercial work and anything where you need to control the exact phrase. This is where per-click pricing earns its place.
Keep the search campaign narrow
A small number of high-intent terms, tight match types, and an actively maintained negative list. Broad targeting on a contractor budget produces clicks from people who were never going to hire anyone.
Track both against booked jobs
Not leads, not calls — booked jobs and their value. The two channels produce different lead quality and the only fair comparison is at the revenue end.
They occupy different parts of the page
On a local service search the page now stacks in a fairly consistent order: Local Services Ads at the very top with the Google Guaranteed badge, then standard search ads, then the map pack, then organic results.
That ordering is most of the argument. LSA is the first thing a homeowner sees, it displays a rating and a badge rather than ad copy, and it converts into a phone call directly from the results page.
Search ads sit below it but offer something LSA does not: you choose the exact searches, write the message, and send people to a page you control. For anything where the specific words matter — a particular system, a commercial job, a brand you are certified for — that control is worth more than the position.
Per-lead versus per-click, and who it favours
LSA charges when someone contacts you. Search ads charge when someone clicks, whether or not they ever make contact.
Per-lead pricing suits businesses with a strong phone process and straightforward services — the risk of paying for non-converting traffic is transferred to Google. Per-click suits businesses that convert well on the page and want to control exactly which searches they appear for.
The cost comparison is not the headline number. An LSA lead costing more than a click is normal and irrelevant. Compare cost per booked job, and accept that it takes a couple of months of real volume to know.
The quiet failures in both
Each channel has a specific way of wasting money that does not look like a problem in the reporting.
For LSA it is undisputed bad leads. Calls for services you do not offer, addresses outside your area, and outright spam all get charged. Google will credit them, and almost nobody files, so a slow leak runs all year.
For search ads it is the negative keyword list nobody maintains. Searches containing "jobs", "salary", "DIY", "how to", "free" and the names of competitors quietly consume budget. Plurals matter too — blocking one form does not block the other, which is a mistake that survives in accounts for years.
Both failures are boring, both are cheap to fix, and both cost more than any bidding strategy decision.
What to do about the automation upsells
Google will recommend broadening targeting, enabling automated campaign types, and turning on the newer AI-driven matching. The recommendation arrives with a vendor-published lift figure attached.
Google reports roughly a 7% conversion lift from the full AI Max for Search suite. Independent testing found 84% of advertisers saw neutral or negative account-level outcomes. Both can be true, because features that need volume to learn help large accounts and hurt small ones.
For a contractor account: do not enable anything that widens targeting until conversion tracking is provably correct and you are consistently producing enough conversions for the system to learn from. Until then, broad automation is paying for the platform’s education.
| Local Services Ads | Google Ads search | |
|---|---|---|
| You pay for | A lead | A click |
| Position on the page | Above everything | Below LSA, above the map |
| Keyword control | Minimal | Complete |
| Landing page | None — it calls you | Yours |
| Requirements | Background check, licence, insurance | A payment method |
| Main leak | Undisputed bad leads | Missing negative keywords |
| Best for | Straightforward residential jobs | Specific, commercial or branded work |
Common questions
- Can I run both at the same time?
- Yes, and most contractors with budget should. They appear in different slots, so you are not bidding against yourself in any meaningful way. Start with LSA if eligible, add search once it is stable, and judge each on cost per booked job rather than on cost per lead.
- Why is my cost per lead so much higher in some months?
- Seasonality and competitor budgets. The first cold week of winter puts every HVAC company in the market into the auction at once. Expect the swing, plan the budget around it, and do not restructure an account in response to a normal seasonal peak.
- Do I need a website to run Local Services Ads?
- Technically no, since the ad produces a call directly. Practically yes, because homeowners check before calling and because everything else — search ads, maps, organic, AI answers — depends on having one. Running LSA with no site means paying for every lead forever with nothing accumulating.
- Who should own the ad account?
- You. If an agency runs campaigns inside an account they own, the conversion history leaves with them, and that history is most of what makes an account efficient. Create the account yourself and grant access.
Where these numbers come from
- Google reports roughly +7% conversions from the full AI Max for Search suite; independent testing found 84% of advertisers saw neutral or negative account-level outcomes.
- — Google product claims vs independent advertiser testing, 2026
- With an AI Overview present, paid click-through rate fell about 68%.
- — Seer Interactive, Jun 2024–Sep 2025
Last reviewed .
Read next
Want this done for your business?
Tell us where you are trying to get to. If the honest answer is that you do not need us, we will say so.